A fair price for an out-of-network MRI is not one national dollar amount. It is a benchmark for the exact scan, in the same care setting and local market, built from what payers have actually agreed to pay for it, with Medicare as a second reference point. The billed charge is the least useful number on the page. It is a provider's asking price, not evidence of what the service is worth.
The data exists and it is public: payer negotiated rates, out-of-network allowed amounts, hospital price files, and Medicare fee schedules. The work is matching them to your claim.
Because "an MRI" is not one service. The price depends on five things, and any one of them can move it more than the others combined.
A national average blends all of that into a number that describes no actual scan. Do not use one to judge a bill.
They are four different numbers, and only some of them tell you what a service is worth in the market.
| Price type | What it is | Use as a fair-price benchmark? |
|---|---|---|
| Billed charge | What the provider bills before any adjustment | No. It is the number in dispute |
| Cash price | What a provider charges a patient who pays without insurance | Useful context for self-pay patients, not a reimbursement benchmark |
| In-network negotiated rate | What a plan has contractually agreed to pay a provider | Yes. The strongest evidence of market price |
| Out-of-network allowed amount | The most a plan will pay a provider it has no contract with | Yes, where published. Shows what plans have actually allowed |
| Medicare amount | What Medicare pays for the same service, setting, and locality | Yes, as an independent reference. Not a required payment |
The definitions for negotiated rate, out-of-network allowed amount, and billed charge come from the federal Transparency in Coverage rules. For more on how these measures differ, see our guide to comparing in-network and out-of-network rates.
In four public sources. Each answers a different part of the question.
Gigasheet gathers and normalizes all of these, including the out-of-network allowed amount files. The out-of-network data is sparse for the reason above, so treat it as a useful cross-check when it exists for your code and market, and lean on the in-network distribution and Medicare when it does not.
Match the claim first, then compare. A supportable benchmark documents what was compared, what was left out, and why the comparison fits the claim.
The result is a range, not a single number: where the middle of the market sits, and how far the bill is from it. For the full claim-level framework, including plan terms and reimbursement methods, read our post on how to determine fair reimbursement for out-of-network claims.
Medicare gives you an independent reference point, and it changes with the setting. Medicare pays hospital outpatient departments under a different payment system than freestanding imaging centers and physician offices, so the same scan has more than one Medicare amount.
Look up the code in the Procedure Price Lookup and use the figure for the setting where the scan was done. For professional services, the Physician Fee Schedule amount also varies by Medicare payment locality.
Two cautions. Medicare is a reference, not the amount a commercial plan or patient is required to pay. And commercial rates usually sit above Medicare, by a margin that varies by market, so no single "percent of Medicare" is fair everywhere. Compare the bill's percent of Medicare with the same figure for in-network rates in your market.
Sometimes. It depends on where and how the scan happened. This is general information from CMS, not legal advice.
State laws can add protections. If you think the Act applies, contact your plan and the No Surprises Help Desk listed on the CMS site.
Start with the itemized bill, the explanation of benefits, and a matched benchmark for the exact service.
A documented benchmark does not guarantee a reduction. It does change the conversation from "this seems high" to "here is what payers in this market pay for this scan."
Gigasheet gives analysts nationwide commercial negotiated rates alongside geographically adjusted Medicare benchmarks, plus published out-of-network allowed amounts where they exist, without building pricing-data infrastructure.
Teams that use it include payment integrity and repricing firms, cost-containment vendors, TPAs and self-insured employers, patient advocates and care navigators, and providers and payers comparing their own markets.
Gigasheet supplies the evidence. It does not determine the legally required reimbursement amount for a claim, and it is not legal advice.
Request a Demo to benchmark your own claims.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026.
There is no single national number. A fair price is a benchmark for the same MRI code, care setting, and local market, built from in-network negotiated rates, any published out-of-network allowed amounts, and the Medicare amount for that service.
Health plans publish them in Transparency in Coverage machine-readable files, and hospitals publish their own in hospital price transparency files. Gigasheet normalizes both so you can search an MRI code by payer, provider, and market.
Yes, but it is thin. Plans publish out-of-network allowed amounts and billed charges, and current rules leave out any provider and service with fewer than 20 claims in the reporting window. Gigasheet collects these files and uses them as a cross-check where they exist.
The two settings are paid on different fee schedules, by Medicare and by commercial payers. That is why the care setting has to match before you compare any two MRI prices.
CPT 70551 is the billing code for an MRI of the brain without contrast. Brain MRIs with contrast, and MRIs of other body parts, use different codes with different rates.
No. A cash price is what a provider charges a patient paying without insurance. It is useful for self-pay shopping, but it is not what payers have agreed to pay for the service.
You can use them as a reference point. Medicare is not the amount a commercial plan or patient is required to pay, so pair it with commercial negotiated rates for the same code and setting in your market.
It depends. CMS says the Act covers emergency care and non-emergency care related to a visit to an in-network hospital, hospital outpatient department, or ambulatory surgical center. It does not apply when you go to an out-of-network facility.
The itemized bill with CPT codes, the explanation of benefits, your plan's out-of-network reimbursement terms, and a documented benchmark for the same service, setting, and market with sources and dates.